Chaos Emerald Bonus Cards from Sonic MTG Drop Fetch Up to $1,500 on Resale Sites

Since you can’t dictate or even predict which Chaos Emerald bonus card you’ll receive in your Magic: The Gathering Sonic Secret Lair order, completing the full set of seven is proving to be a costly challenge. With almost all Sonic Secret Lair drops sold out, and each order containing only one random Emerald color, collectors are already turning to resale markets.

Listings for these Chaos Emerald bonus cards have started popping up on eBay, with asking prices climbing quickly. The cards are arriving in waves, and the first wave of deliveries has clearly landed, sparking a flood of resale listings. If you’re hoping to collect all seven Chaos Emeralds without relying on pure luck, prepare to spend thousands.

Prices vary widely. While most individual cards are being listed for $400 to $600, there are outliers. One listing offers a single card for a staggering $1,500, while another bundles the blue, red, and yellow Emeralds together for $1,600 — a relative bargain by comparison. The most realistic barometer of value so far is a foil silver Chaos Emerald currently up for bid, already reaching $232.50 with 23 bids and over three days remaining.

As the MTG x Sonic Secret Lair continues shipping out, more listings are expected to emerge. But for die-hard Sonic and Magic collectors, finishing the set will likely mean braving the high-stakes world of resale.

Stay tuned to Sonic City for more MTG x Sonic News and Updates!